Is A Swimming Pool Worth It? A Complete Guide

BackyardBooster.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no added cost to you. Learn more.

Imagine a fine beautiful evening, cocktail in hand, dinner on the grill, and you’re sitting poolside— all in the comfort of your own backyard. Wonderful, isn’t it? It sounds like a dream come true, but deciding to install a pool isn’t as simple as it sounds. So, is adding a backyard swimming pool worth it?

Benefits of A Swimming Pool

According to the US Census, swimming is one of the most popular outdoor activities in the United States, second only to morning walks.

It can increase flexibility, stretch muscles, and help you lose weight.

Exercise physiologist and triathlete Tom Holland said that an hour of intense swimming could burn 700 calories.

Swimming also benefits mental health. Marine biologist Wallace J. Nichols, in his book “Blue Heart,” explained how contact with water makes people feel better.

He mentioned it allows us to enter a “quiet contemplation state” that comes with calmness, peace, unity, general well-being, and life satisfaction.

Is A Swimming Pool Worth It?

Buying an outdoor swimming pool for your home is a big decision. Many homeowners want to know if adding a swimming pool is a worthy investment.

Let’s be honest. Backyard swimming pools sound great. We all want a pool in our backyard during those hot summer months. But pool ownership is no easy task.

So, is getting a swimming pool worth it? Let’s take a look.

This article breaks down a list of factors you should consider before deciding whether a swimming pool is worth it for your backyard.

Above-Ground vs In-Ground Swimming Pool: What’s the Difference?

When you want to add a new swimming pool to your home, the most important decision is whether you’ll buy an above-ground pool or an in-ground pool.

There are many factors to consider when choosing between the two. For example, there are differences in features, cost, material, pool maintenance, space requirements, etc.

Whichever type you choose, the backyard view and pool experience will be vastly different. This is the most important decision for future pool owners to make, but how do you choose?

There are some pros and cons to consider before deciding what type of swimming pool you want in your home.

Feature Differences

Above-Ground Pool

Above-ground swimming pools typically stand 3 feet to 5 feet above the ground. 

Many people build a tall deck around it to make it as high as the pool to accommodate easy entry into the pool.

It’s fair to say, people living in colder climates and with tighter budgets usually prefer above-ground pools.

In-Ground Pool

The in-ground pool is just how it sounds; it’s installed in the ground at the same height as your backyard.

The in-ground pool gives the feeling of more space in your yard since the pool’s depth is hidden below the ground. However, in-ground pools can be expensive and may not be suitable for all climates.

Cost Difference

Above-Ground Pool

On average, depending on the size, height, material, shape, and the installation cost of setting up an above-ground swimming pool is between $900 and $3,000. If you have handy professional skills, you can buy a DIY pool kit and install it yourself.

In-Ground Pool

The installation cost of an in-ground swimming pool ranges from $5,000 to $45,000. Prices can vary depending on several factors: the shape and size of your pool, the depth, your location, and the builder you are hiring.

Adding an in-ground pool is a serious home improvement project.

While installing an in-ground pool can increase your home’s resale value, the increase in value usually doesn’t match the cost of installing and maintaining a pool.

Material Difference

Above-Ground Pool

Above-ground swimming pools are usually built with kits purchased from stores, so distinct parts are made of varying materials.

Aluminum pools are the most popular and durable, while resin pools are also extremely popular. Iron and steel can be used for the swimming pool walls, but they can rust and deteriorate more quickly.

Aluminum can oxidize over time as well, but it takes years to do so. If the above-ground swimming pool has thick aluminum walls, it can easily last for decades.

In-Ground Pool

On the other hand, in-ground swimming pools are traditionally made of concrete, but fiberglass or vinyl swimming pools are becoming increasingly popular.

Placing colored tiles (usually blue) over the concrete floor can create a decorative effect.

Installation Time

Above-Ground Pool

Unless you need to remove grass, bushes, and debris or level the ground, above-ground pools are fairly quick to install.

It can take about a day to build an above-ground swimming pool with the proper tools and help. However, if the pool is significant in size, it can take up to two to five days.

Above-ground pools are also relatively quick and easy to remove if you no longer want your pool.

In-Ground Pool

The in-ground swimming pool can take much longer, at around 6-8 weeks, to complete. The construction effort includes clearing the space, digging, building the swimming pool itself, and installing cleaning mechanisms.

In case of harsh weather or the rainy season, construction may take several additional weeks to complete.

On the other hand, if the swimming pool is made of vinyl fiber or fiberglass, it may take less than six weeks to be installed.

Pros & Cons of Each

Pros of Above-Ground Pool

• The above-ground swimming pool is a temporary swimming pool, which means it can easily be installed anywhere, even in a rental house. You can also undo parts on some models and rebuild them in other homes when you decide to move.
• Above-ground swimming pools are much cheaper than in-ground swimming pools
• These pools are also easy to maintain. There is no need for regular cleaning, filtering, bleaching, or refilling. If the above-ground swimming pool is small, you can easily cover it with a rubber blanket.
• These swimming pools are easy to set up and usually take less than a day. With the right technical knowledge, you can set up the pool by yourself.

Cons of Above-Ground Pool

• The above-ground swimming pool adds zero value to your home. If you plan to rent or sell your home, you need to build an in-ground swimming pool to add value to your property. Ask your real estate agent how much value a pool would add.
• If you have a pool in your backyard, it will damage the grass that grows underneath it. After dismantling the pool or moving it to another location, you will need to repair the lawn underneath.
• In-ground pools are permanent and have a long-lasting life, whereas above-ground pools are more prone to damage. Besides, they do not last long, and if used frequently, they may need to be replaced after a few years.

Pros of In-Ground Pool

• With an in-ground swimming pool, you can design it to your liking, in any shape, size, and depth. You can choose a classic rectangle (oval or curved) to cover a minimal space or occupy the entire backyard.
• You can add different depths to the same swimming pool, mini-depth corners, or one side for children and the other side for adults, with or without a central safety fence. This is safer for your family if you have children who love to swim and have fun in the water.
• An in-ground swimming pool can add value to your property. The more you spend building a swimming pool, the higher your reputation for luxury gets, and the more valuable your home will be.
• Such pools cannot be easily damaged. You may need to filter the water and clean the pool regularly, but this will not damage the pool’s structure or construction. Setting up an in-ground pool means you and your family can use it regularly for decades.

Cons of In-Ground Pool

• Building an in-ground swimming pool costs several times more than an above-ground swimming pool. The cost difference mainly rests on it being a permanent fixture in your home and involves much more effort than cleaning, digging up areas, buildings, maintenance, etc.
• Your costs don’t just end with constructing a swimming pool; installing a water filtration system, automatic or manual swimming pool covers, accessories, and maintenance are the other costs that add up. These swimming pools require regular inspection and maintenance by a professional and may even require expert cleaning.
• The in-ground swimming pool will exist forever, or at least for a few decades. The construction costs can be expensive to close and fill up a swimming pool. Anyone who wants to build an in-ground pool in their home should be confident of everything involved.

Average Size of a Swimming Pool

The average in-ground swimming pool size in the United States is approximately 450 square feet.

If you are considering creating a swimming pool large enough for your family, target small and medium-sized swimming pools. The average area of a medium-sized swimming pool is about 600 square feet.

A swimming pool with an area in the range of 400 to 800 square feet is ideal for most families. However, to reduce costs, many families opt for a smaller size of about 350 square feet.

Before you pull the trigger to install a pool in your backyard, you should make sure you have enough room in your backyard to do so.

Pool Maintenance Costs

Ask any pool owner – owning a pool is a considerable investment. Maintenance can sometimes add up to thousands of dollars per year.

The initial cost of setting up a swimming pool can be high, and many people do not consider the maintenance costs.

The costs of maintenance mostly include cleaning, chemicals, and filters. And you will incur costs during both the swimming season and non-swimming season.

Understanding the long-term costs is key in determining whether a swimming pool is worth it or not. So, calculate these costs before you get a pool.

Cleaning

In an outdoor swimming pool, leaves and dirt often find their way into the pool. You’ll certainly want a pool cover (not as necessary for an indoor pool).

Skimming the pool surface with a pool net will remove any debris floating on the water’s surface. This should be performed several times a week.

The cost of a pool net is fairly inexpensive, approximately $20-$30.

The walls of the swimming pool should be brushed properly. Otherwise, it will accumulate dirt and bacteria over time.

Certain types of pools (concrete and vinyl) are more prone to algae growth than others. Therefore, the walls should be brushed once a week to maintain proper cleanliness.

A hard-bristled brush is required for dense concrete walls. While fiberglass, tile, and vinyl pools require the use of soft brushes. These brushes cost approximately $10-$20.

Vacuuming the pool is also crucial. Any debris may fall to the bottom of the swimming pool and ruin the pool’s beauty.

The average cost of an automatic pool vacuum cleaner is about $600. You can buy a manually operated pool vacuum for a lower price, but you’ll need to make sure you’re cleaning at least once a week.

Chemicals

It is difficult to determine the average cost of these chemicals because every pool is different. However, the Wall Street Journal estimates that the cost of chemicals can be up to $500-$800 per year.

Chemicals for swimming pools used throughout the year will be more expensive than pools that are only used seasonally.

The cost will also depend on the types of chemicals you plan to use for treatment, including chlorine, algaecides, and/or saltwater. But, again, there’s plenty of information online to help you determine which chemicals you’ll need for your pool.

Saltwater pools are an interesting option for those who want a more natural approach to their pool.

It’s best to hire a professional to ensure that you have the appropriate chemical balance in your swimming pool. This is key to providing you and your family have a safe and healthy pool environment.  

Filters

A new pool filter must be installed every 3 to 5 years, costing you between $500 and $2,000 for each replacement.

You can reduce these costs by keeping the pool clean and skimming frequently. However, just using the pool can bring in some dirt.

So, Is A Swimming Pool Worth It?

Having your swimming pool in the privacy of your backyard can be a dream. Furthermore, backyard pools provide you with your own area to exercise, relax, entertain guests, and enjoy yourself with your family.

Is there a public pool nearby? If so, maybe you don’t need one in your backyard.

It’s a good idea to sit down, look at your finances, and see what fits within your budget.

Most times, the increase in your home’s value doesn’t justify the installation and maintenance costs of installing a pool. 

However, if you and your family are active and like spending time outdoors, having the occasional pool party, and having fun together, then the investment will be less about your home’s value and more about the extra time you spend with your family and friends.

Now that you’ve reviewed the considerations, do you think adding a swimming pool is worth it for you? Let us know!

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I Need Liability Coverage Insurance If Own a Backyard Pool?

Yes, if you want to protect yourself against pool-related medical expenses or unexpected damages, it’s a very good idea to get liability coverage insurance.

How to Drain A Pool?

You can get a submersible pump and use it to drain your pool. First, the pool pump should be submerged in water, and then you can use it to pump the water out of the pool.  

These pumps often come with certain types of filters to treat the water before you discharge it.

Work with your local water authority to determine whether you can drain to the street or your local sewer drain.

Will Pool Water Kill Grass?

Pool water itself doesn’t usually kill the grass. However, some grass may die off due to excess chlorine or salt found in the pool water.

Is A House with a Pool Worth More? Does a Swimming Pool Increase My Home Value?

The value of a house with a pool can vary depending on several factors, including the location, size and condition of the pool, and local market conditions. In some areas, having a pool may increase the value of a house, while in other areas it may not have as much of an impact on the price.

In general, pools can be seen as an attractive amenity for some homebuyers, as they provide opportunities for relaxation, recreation, and entertainment. Families with children or individuals who enjoy swimming and hosting pool parties may be willing to pay a premium for a house with a pool. Additionally, in warm climates where swimming is popular year-round, a pool can be a desirable feature that adds to the overall appeal of a property.

However, it’s important to consider that pools also come with ongoing costs, such as maintenance, utilities, and insurance. Some homebuyers may also view pools as a potential safety concern, especially if they have young children or are not experienced swimmers. In some cases, buyers may prefer not to have a pool due to the associated costs, maintenance responsibilities, or safety concerns, and may not be willing to pay extra for a house with a pool.